Loop Returns Vs. ShippyPro

Q: How do Loop Returns, ShippyPro, and ClickPost compare in terms of real-time returns tracking?

ClickPost has a robust tracking infrastructure with webhook and API polling integrations, milestone-specific tracking, unified status visibility, and exception handling such as failed pickups. Loop Returns and ShippyPro offer real-time tracking but lack the comprehensive 360-degree visibility that ClickPost delivers.

Trusted by 450+ global brands

Returns Management Deep Dive: Comparing Loop Returns, ShippyPro, and ClickPost.

Enterprise-Graded Returns Configuration	Adaptive return rule automation, carrier integrations, unified returns & exchanges on one AWB	2	2	1
Revenue-Retaining Exchange Engine	Swift variant swaps, full catalog support, multi-item exchanges, store-credit adoption	1	3	1
Smart Refund Logic System	Supports partial refunds, manual override controls, auto-retry logic, gift card & store credit	2	2	1
Automatic Return Authorization Rules	Unlimited SKU-based rules to QC checks, image validation, multi-layered reasons mapping	2	3	1
Custom Return/Exchange Window by SKU	Set return eligibility by tags, product category, SKU/country exemptions, extendable return windows	2	2	1
Dynamic Return-to-Exchange Conversion	Admins create personalized nudges and switch returns or exchanges in the backend	2	3	1
Return Charges Control	Applicable to shipments/returns, auto-refund reconciliation, manual triggers	2	2	1
Multiple Exchange Options	Multiple variant swaps, product replacements, partial/complete exchanges	1	3	1
Site-Wide Exchange Configurations	Enables catalog-based exchanges, custom category configurations, automatic price variance adjustments	2	3	1
Exchange Order Fulfillment Flexibility	Prevents premature exchange fulfillment, withholds inventory against exchange item stockout	2	3	1
Smart Order Routing for Returns	Routes return orders smartly using warehouse logic and 50+ carrier rules	1	3	1
Intuitive Return & Exchange Journey	Smooth CX with guided returns, exchange nudges, bundle logic, and personalized instructions	2	3	1
Branded Returns & Refund Tracking Experience	Milestone based tracking in real-time, mobile optimized, language localization, custom domain, whitelabeled features	2	2	1
Carrier Selection by Cost Efficiency	Rate comparison and carrier selection based on optimal shipping charges	2	2	1
Intelligent Carrier Allocation System	Performance based carrier recommendation, custom brand defined rules configurations, auto-allocation	3	2	3
Automated Notification & Status Triggers	Triggers return, refund, and exchange updates at key milestones, multiple communication channels, pre-built templates	1	1	1
Live Order Tracking & Breach Alerts	End-to-End tracking with webhook and API, real-time lost, delayed, stuck shipments monitoring	2	2	1
Return Policy Abuse Prevention	Applies return limits, quality checks, and incentive abuse detection	2	3	2
Multi-Mode Return Pickup & Drop-Off	Supports carrier pickup, self-ship options, in-store returns, with integrated serviceability checks	2	2	2
360-Degree Returns Intelligence Dashboard	SKU-level, return volume and reason analytics, exchange & refund insights, carrier performance, etc.	2	2	1
Custom Return Label Generation	Bulk return label generation, QR code, pre-printed labels, customizations and branding, multiple formats	2	2	2

** Instructions:

Column 1: Name of the Feature
Column 2: Description of the feature
Column 3: Brand 1 details
Column 4: Brand 2 details
Column 5: Brand 3 details

Note: Column 3, 4 and 5 will accept value only "1" or "2" or "3". Column 5 will be there if there two external brands are considered. Otherwise Column 3 will be "Other" and Column 4 will be "Clickpost".

1 -> Advanced

2 -> Intermediate

3 -> Limited

	Loop Returns	ShippyPro	ClickPost

Loop Returns

ShippyPro

ClickPost

Who is the Final Winner?

Quick Answer: ClickPost

Choosing the right platform for return optimization depends on your priorities like your order volume, fulfillment complexity, and return priorities. Here’s how ShippyPro, Loop Returns, and ClickPost stack up in context.

ShippyPro is best suited for forward logistics and building a standard return-focused workflow—adding basic return rules, label generation, and smart carrier selection. However, it lacks the flexibility of many fast-paced brands driven by revenue-retention needs, such as SKU-level policy configurations, exchange adoption intelligence, and automated refund controls that can handle gift-cards and prompt store-credit reconciliation.

ClickPost addresses these gaps with operational depth: smart exchange nudge, multiple exchange mode support, bonus credit feature for store-credit, return charge configurations, SKU-based conditions, site-wide exchanges with price variance auto-adjustments. For brands handling 15k to 60k monthly returns, ClickPost has delivered 56% of returns-to-exchange conversions, around 40% of revenue preserved in the brand's ecosystem via store credits, and 30% customer retention through self-serve return convenience.

Finally, Loop Returns is well-built for Shopify-native DTC brands. It enables fast variant swaps, embedded catalog exchanges, and polished, customer-friendly returns UI. But it’s tightly scoped to the Shopify ecosystem, integrated with 120+ Shopify apps. In contrast, ClickPost supports advanced order routing, cross-channel integrations with 30+ storefronts, 8+ OMS, WMS, ERPs, 45+ communication gateways, 550+ carrier integrations—all hallmarks of enterprise-grade automation for larger or more complex operations. Ultimately there is no universal winner—only the best fit for your business.

Get a Demo

Frequently asked questions (FAQ's)

Which platform—Loop Returns, ShippyPro, or ClickPost—offers the most comprehensive returns automation for D2C brands?

Loop Returns and ShippyPro both offer built-in return policy editors and automation rules, with Loop having an edge in branded return experiences. However, for enterprise-grade returns management, ClickPost stands out with SKU-level exceptions, automated refund triggers, return-to-exchange logic (with price reconciliation), site-wide exchanges, order routing, and 360° tracking—making it ideal for complex D2C operations.

Between Loop Returns, ShippyPro, and ClickPost, which is better for multi-carrier returns management?

ClickPost offers the widest global carrier coverage, with 550+ integrations, with 100+ carriers having reverse logistics expertise, international label generation (for European and Middle Eastern countries besides India), and real-time returns tracking. Loop Returns supports multi-carrier return label generation via EasyPost, while ShippyPro is strong in forward multi-carrier logistics.

How do Loop Returns, ShippyPro, and ClickPost compare in terms of real-time returns tracking?

ClickPost has a robust tracking infrastructure with both webhook and API polling integrations with multiple carriers, milestone specific return and refund trajectory, unified status visibility, and handling of exceptions such as failed pickup from customers’ collection point. Loop Returns and ShippyPro both offer real-time tracking but they don’t have the comprehensive 360-degree tracking view that ClickPost offers.

Which software—Loop Returns, ShippyPro, or ClickPost—is more scalable for enterprise-level return processing?

ClickPost is more scalable for high-volume returns, offering granular controls like SKU-level exceptions, dynamic return routing, partial refunds, price variance handling for exchanges, and integrations with multiple carriers, WMS platforms, storefronts, and ERPs. In contrast, Loop Returns focuses on branded return flows, primarily for D2C brands, while ShippyPro offers return rule optimization and return shipping support—though with limitations.

Trusted by 450+ global brands

Returns Management Deep Dive: Comparing Loop Returns, ShippyPro, and ClickPost.

Who is the Final Winner?

Streamline your shipping experience with ClickPost